Judge Lets Trump's $15B Suit Against New York Times Proceed
U.S. District Judge Steven Merryday ruled Thursday that Trump's defamation suit against The New York Times and Penguin Random House may proceed.
- $15 billion in damages is what Trump seeks from the Times and Penguin.
- 2 of Trump's claims were dismissed; the core defamation claims survived.
- 34 challenged statements: 22 tied to Peter Baker, 12 to Craig and Buettner.
- The suit targets the 2024 book Lucky Loser and related Times articles.
Why it matters: Merryday found Trump plausibly alleged that claims he committed complex crimes were "based on incomplete, minimal information." That includes the statement that he received over $400 million from his father, largely through tax evasion.
- The judge said publishers needed forensic auditing before alleging tax crimes.
- He ruled other statements are protected under Times v. Sullivan.
How 11 sources split on this story
Where they split: Coverage differs on the ruling's scope: most outlets say two claims were dismissed, while the Times says nearly all claims against it were thrown out.
Center coverage, 2 sources: The center frames it as a sharp courtroom victory for Trump, highlighting the judge's pointed language and both sides' competing claims of success.
Left coverage, 6 sources: The left treats the ruling as a win in Trump's broader campaign against news outlets, which critics including Reporters Without Borders tie to declining press freedom.
Right coverage, 3 sources: The right focuses on the judge's finding that the tax-fraud allegations rested on thin information and lacked forensic support.
What’s next: The case heads toward discovery and possibly trial. It may not finish before Trump leaves office in 2029.
- Times spokesperson Charlie Stadtlander said the remaining claim has "no legal merit" and the paper will keep fighting.
- A separate $10 billion Trump suit against the BBC was also recently allowed to proceed.
- Which specific statements and defendants remain in the case after the dismissals?
- Will the Times and Penguin seek to settle or appeal before discovery?














