Supreme Court Declines Challenge to Gun Bans in Sensitive Places
The Supreme Court on Monday declined to hear a challenge to Maryland's restrictions on carrying guns in sensitive places. The laws remain in effect.
- Maryland bans guns in schools, transit, parks, hospitals and alcohol-serving venues.
- 10 categories of places were targeted in the consolidated lawsuits.
- The 4th Circuit upheld all challenged restrictions under the court's historical test.
- Justice Thomas agreed with the denial but said he doubts the laws are lawful.
Why it matters: The court's 2022 Bruen ruling allowed gun bans in sensitive places but never defined the term. Lower courts have since split on reasoning and locations.
- Some Maryland limits were enacted in 2023, after Bruen expanded carry rights.
- Thomas said challenging many laws at once would complicate the court's review.
How 18 sources split on this story
Where they split: The dispute is whether Maryland's list follows a historical tradition of location bans or makes carry permits practically useless in public.
Center coverage, 5 sources: The center sees the court again dodging a gun dispute as it struggles to apply its 2022 historical test.
Left coverage, 4 sources: The left sees the court sidestepping a defining question while its conservative majority continues to signal skepticism of broad state gun limits.
Right coverage, 9 sources: The right sees a missed chance to strike down what it calls gun-free zones, leaving gun owners to fight bans piecemeal.
What’s next: The justices hear arguments in December on state bans of assault-style weapons.
- A pending petition challenges New York's ban on guns in public parks.
- New York's response in that case is due Dec. 3.
- Will the court take a narrower sensitive-places case, and which location would it test?
- How will lower courts apply the historical test to modern places like transit and entertainment venues?






















