The story so far
- Report: Stahl Weighed Quitting 60 Minutes After Weiss PushbackYou are here
- Bari Weiss Threats Leaked From Tense CBS News Meeting4 sourcesLatest
Updated 4d ago · Entertainment
Report: Stahl Weighed Quitting 60 Minutes After Weiss Pushback
60 Minutes aired Lesley Stahl's report on settler violence in the West Bank on Sunday. Status reported that the segment aired only after a heated internal review led by Bari Weiss.
- 20% of the West Bank is now taken over by settlers' flocks, the report said.
- 100-plus Palestinian communities have been displaced or erased, Stahl said.
- Weiss and deputy Charles Forelle gave broad notes, and Forelle suggested delaying the piece.
- CBS called the Status account a ludicrous, twisted narrative.
Why it matters: Critics accuse Weiss of tilting CBS coverage toward the Trump administration and the Israeli government. That makes her handling of this report a point of scrutiny.
- Sources compared it to the pulled CECOT segment by Sharyn Alfonsi.
- Stahl said Democrats threaten to limit military aid to Israel if they win.
How 9 sources split on this story
Source landscape
Factuality
High
Mixed
Low
Strong LeftLeftLean LeftCenterLean RightRightStrong Right
Political Bias
Coverage by lean
9 sources · 15 articles · 56% Left coverage
Where they split: Outlets disagree over whether Weiss's leadership is softening CBS coverage of Israel or whether 60 Minutes remains critical of Israel and Republicans.
Center coverage, 1 sources: The center focuses on the newsroom conflict, giving both the Status account and CBS's rebuttal about timing and routine editing.
Left coverage, 5 sources: The left sees Weiss's hands-on review as another case of leadership pressure on reporting critical of Israel and the Trump administration.
The Independent6dCBS News’ Bari Weiss clashes with another veteran reporter over Israeli piece: reportRaw Story5d'Jaws on the floor' as Bari Weiss hire threatened firings in '15-minute tirade': reportMediaite5dDetails Leak From Explosive Meeting Where Bari Weiss’s ‘Handpicked’ Editor Threatened CB ...Variety4d'60 Minutes' Sees Audience Dip Without NFL Lead-InThe New Republic6d60 Minutes Star Nearly Quit After Fight With Bari Weiss
Right coverage, 3 sources: The right sees the report as proof that 60 Minutes still leans against Israel and toward Democrats, or treats it as an investigation of settler tactics.
NewsBusters1w+Revamped ‘60 Minutes’ Hits Israel Over West Bank, Stahl Implies Dems Will Help End ViolenceDaily Mail4dCBS News London bureau staffers reprimanded after edits to Gaza war segment and cut Palestinian death toll were 'leaked' to press, report claimsNew York Post5dLesley Stahl 'would never quit' '60 Minutes' despite reported tiff with CBS News' Bari Weiss: sources
What’s next: A CBS source said the segment reached editors late Thursday, which left little time before airtime. The network says the piece received fewer edits than most.
- Status also reported a dispute over a Gaza death toll in an Oct. 7 report.
- What specific changes did Weiss and Forelle seek in the segment?
- Will Stahl or Holly Williams stay at CBS long term?
View all