DOJ Files Complaint Against Minnesota Judges Over Immigration Interviews
Attorney General Todd Blanche announced Wednesday that the DOJ had filed a judicial misconduct complaint against six of Minnesota's seven active federal district judges with the 8th Circuit Court of Appeals. The complaint stems from interviews those judges gave the New York Times about the Trump administration's immigration enforcement surge in Minnesota.
- 6 of 7 active Minnesota federal district judges spoke to the Times for the article.
- The complaint specifically names Judge Patrick Schiltz and Judge John Tunheim by name.
- DOJ asks the 8th Circuit to bar named judges from all DHS-related cases.
- The complaint is signed by Acting Deputy AG Trent McCotter and Associate AG Stanley Woodward.
Why it matters: The complaint escalates a sustained conflict between the Trump administration and the federal judiciary that intensified during Minnesota's winter immigration enforcement surge, called Operation Metro Surge.
- Schiltz previously identified 96 court orders in 74 cases he said ICE had violated during the surge.
- Two people were killed in Minnesota in January during clashes between federal authorities and protesters amid the enforcement campaign.
How 38 sources split on this story
Where they split: The core dispute is whether the judges' interviews constituted unethical partisan conduct or a legitimate public accounting of executive-branch violations of court orders.
Center coverage, 11 sources: The center presents the complaint as a significant and unusual executive action, laying out both the DOJ's ethics allegations and the judges' stated concerns about compliance with court orders.
CNBC1dDOJ accuses Minnesota federal judges of misconduct for NY Times immigration interviews
Reuters1dUS Justice Department files complaint against Minnesota judges who gave interviews about immigration surge
Axios1dTrump's DOJ takes its fight with federal judges to Minnesota
Law and Crime11hJudge's 'outrageous' move to say he doesn't want US to become North Korea should force his recusal from 'any' DHS matters, Trump DOJ demands
Newsweek1dTrump DOJ says judges waged "partisan press campaign" over ICE operationNOTNOTUS1dDOJ Wants Federal Judges Sidelined for Criticisms of ICE Crackdown - The Washington Sun
PBS NewsHour1dWATCH: Justice Department files complaint against judges over immigration enforcement surge comments
The Hill1dDOJ seeks to censure judges who spokes to NYT about Minnesota immigration raidsWNWESH 2 News1dDepartment of Justice files complaint against judges over immigration enforcement surge commentsWGAWGAL 81dDepartment of Justice files complaint against judges over immigration enforcement surge commentsWYWKBN Youngstown1dJustice Department files complaint against judges over immigration enforcement surge commentsLeft coverage, 14 sources: The left frames the complaint as an escalation in the Trump administration's pattern of retaliating against judges who rule against its agenda, noting past failed attempts to pressure the judiciary.
CNN1dDOJ ramps up fight against federal judges after some in Minnesota speak to media about immigration surge cases
CBS News1dJustice Department files judicial misconduct complaint against federal judges in Minnesota
Raw Story2hJudge charges ahead with possible charges for Trump prosecutor over crackdown fallout
MSNBC3hNearly all Minnesota’s active federal judges spoke out on the immigration surge. Did they violate ethics rules?
Mediaite1dReporter Straight Up Asks Todd Blanche If He’s Becoming a ‘Political Actor’ With His MAG ...
The Independent1dDOJ looks to censure judges who spoke to the NYT about Minnesota ICE crackdown
Al Jazeera1dTrump administration files complaint against judges over media comments
HuffPost2dAppeals Court Appears Ready To Let Judge Investigate Trump Officials Who Defied His OrderMeiMeidasTouch1dTrump’s DOJ Gets Hammered Over Deportation Flights, Contempt Probe May Resume
Politico1dJustice Department files ethics complaint against Minnesota federal judges
Talking Points Memo7hTrump DOJ Doubles Down on Attacking JudgesTNRThe New Republic1dDOJ Prepares to Investigate Nearly Every Federal Judge in Blue StateRight coverage, 13 sources: The right frames the judges' interviews as inappropriately partisan conduct that undermined judicial impartiality and justified the DOJ's recusal demand.
Just the News2dDOJ files misconduct complaints against Minnesota judges who spoke to NYT
The Epoch Times2dDOJ Files Ethics Complaint Against Minnesota Judges Who Spoke to NYT
Breitbart News1dDOJ Files Charges Against Judges Who Collaborated to Undermine ICE
Newsmax1dDOJ: Minnesota Judges 'Undermined Public Confidence'
NTD1dDOJ Files Ethics Complaint Against Minnesota Judges Who Spoke to NYT
One America News1dDOJ files misconduct complaint against Minn. judges over NYT comments: 'A clear violation of their ethical duties'
PJ Media1dDOJ Just Turned My Minnesota Judges Question Into a Formal Misconduct Case
RedState1dThumbs on the Scale: DOJ Files Misconduct Complaint Against MN Judges Who Blabbed to NYTimes
The Federalist8hDOJ Files Complaint Against Judges For 'Pandering' To NYT About ICE
The Washington Times1dDOJ seeks penalties for Minnesota judges who gave press interview criticizing Trump on immigration
Townhall22hWhy AG Todd Blanche Cited Virtually the Entire Federal Bench in Minnesota for Misconduct
Washington Examiner1dDOJ charges 10 in Minnesota voting caseWhat’s next: The 8th Circuit must decide whether to accept, investigate, or dismiss the misconduct complaint.
- Blanche called on the district judges to recuse themselves from DHS cases while the complaint is pending.
- Will the 8th Circuit order recusals or open a formal investigation, given that earlier DOJ pressure campaigns against judges produced no disciplinary action?
- Did the judges' public comments cross ethical lines under the Code of Judicial Conduct, or fall within permissible speech about court administration?